Three Ingredient Freezer Dog Treats (Homemade Pumpkin Bites)
Easy 3 Ingredient Freezer Dog Treats
If your dogs (or cats!) love a cool treat now and then, then these easy 3 ingredient freezer dog treats are perfect – and they’re so simple. I mix plain Greek yogurt, a spoonful of natural peanut butter and some pumpkin puree, then spoon the mixture into silicone molds. And after a few hours in the freezer, they pop right out into creamy little bites the dogs absolutely love.
What I like about these frozen dog treats is how quick they are to make – no cooking, no fuss, and just three everyday ingredients I already keep in the kitchen. The pumpkin is gentle on their stomachs, the yogurt gives them a nice creamy texture, and the peanut butter…well, that’s the part that gets tails wagging the minute the container comes out.
Once I made these, I haven’t gone back to store bought treats since. My dog loves them. They cost pennies to make, and I know exactly what’s in every single bite. There are no fillers, no artificial colors and no weird preservatives. Just real food.
Why Homemade 3 Ingredient Freezer Dog Treats Are Better (and Cheaper)
It was surprising, I found that I was spending a huge amount of money on store-bought treats that easily run $10–$20 a bag, especially the ones labeled “natural,” “grain-free,” or “healthy.” So, I decided to make my own. And when I make my own, most batches cost between $4-6 and make several dozen treats.
Plus, most recipes use things I already have:
- Peanut Butter (all- natural)
- Pumpkin puree (canned)
- Yogurt (plain)
I can mix everything in one bowl, bake them quickly, then store them for weeks. And, since I shape them myself, nothing goes to waste — I make small training treats or bigger snacks depending on what my dogs need.
Are Homemade 3 Ingredient Freezer Dog Treats Healthier for Dogs? Absolutely.
Homemade treats let you control every single ingredient. No dyes, no chemical preservatives, no mystery “meat meal.”
Here’s what I’ve noticed:
- Better digestion — oats and pumpkin are gentle on sensitive tummies
- Steady energy — peanut butter and eggs add natural protein
- Fewer allergy issues — you can skip chicken, wheat, or anything your dog reacts to
It just feels good knowing exactly what I’m feeding them.
DISCLAIMER: This page contains affiliate links. Purchases made through such links will reward me a small commission at no extra cost for you. I always have my readers’ best interest at heart. Also, as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. See our Disclosure Policy.
A Quick Note About Feeding (and Why We Love Zeal)
Before the homemade dog treats come out, our pets always get their regular food – that’s the rule in our house. And lately I’ve been using Zeal Pet Food as their main meal because every time I open a can, everyone shows up in the kitchen. The ingredients are simple, wholesome, and made with real nutrition in mind — perfect for a dog that deserves the best. Even the cats wander in when they hear the can open.
They don’t get treats until they eat their food first – but a little frozen pumpkin dog treat after feels like fun bonus for them. So, I always make sure I keep a batch ready in the freezer.
How to Make 3 Ingredient Freezer Dog Treats
Here’s how I make these quick 3 ingredient freezer dog treats. It only takes a couple of minutes to stir everything together.
3 Ingredient Freezer Dog Treats
Equipment
- silicone molded tray can use ice cube tray
Ingredients
- ⅓ cup pumpkin puree organic
- ⅓ cup peanut butter organic
- 16 oz plain yogurt sheep, goat, or your brand
Instructions
Gather Equipment and Ingredients
- Gather measuring cups, mixing spoon and mixing bowl.
Mix and Prep
- Measure 1/3 cup pumpkin puree.
- Add to Mixing bowl.
- Measure 1/3 cup peanut butter (organic/natural).
- Add to mixing bowl and mix with pumpkin puree.
- Once mixed, add plain yogurt.
- Mix well.
Freeze
- Using Tablespoon, spoon into silicone molder trays (or ice cube tray).
- Place in freezer for 3-4 hours to harden. Ensure it is lying flat.
Storing
- Remove from tray and store in storage container or freezer bag.
- Recipe makes approximately 20 treats.
Zeal Pet Food – My Honest Take
“I tested Zeal’s chicken recipe one night and honestly wasn’t expecting much. After mixing a little canned Zeal into their dry food — the next thing I knew, all three cats (yes, I have cats, too) were lined up, one nudging the others to get closer. Even the dogs were waiting by the counter to see if they’d get a taste. It passed the sniff test fast.” This was when started the dogs on Zeal Dog Food.
Storage Tips
These three ingredient freezer dog treats freeze beautifully and keep their shape well. Once they’re solid, I pop them out of the molds. then I move them to a freezer bag, so they take up less space. That way they are easier to grab whenever the pets want a cool snack.
- They last about 2 months in the freezer.
- For smaller dogs, spoon the mixer into mini molds so the portions are tiny and easy to manage.
- If the mixture if a bit thick to spoon, add a teaspoon of water to thin it out.
Tools I Use
- Silicone Cooking Spoons → Shappy 4 Pieces Silicone Cooking Spoons 10.6 Inch Heat Resistant Kitchen Spoons for Mixing, Serving and Stirring Upgrade Large Non Stick Basting Utensils, Dishwasher Safe(Spoon,Fashionable Color)
- Silicone treat mold → homEdge Puppy Dog Paw and Bone Silicone Molds, Non-Stick Food Grade Silicone Molds for Chocolate, Candy, Jelly, Ice Cube, Dog Treats (Puppy Paw Bone Set of 4PCS)
- Measuring cups → Spring Chef Magnetic Stainless Steel Measuring Cups, Patented, Kitchen Tools with Easy to Read Markings for Measuring Dry or Liquid Ingredients, Set of 7, Black
Want a Simple Way to Start Your Mornings?
If you love keeping life cozy and organized, you’ll enjoy the free Plan My Day Checklist I use each morning. This is a gentle, no-pressure way to set your priorities without feeling overwhelmed.
It is simple, quick and calming. And honestly —it just makes the day feel smoother. (This prints perfectly or works on your phone.)
Download your FREE Plan My Day Checklist.
Final Thoughts
What started as a way to save money has turned into something much more meaningful. I love knowing exactly what my dog is eating and I love avoiding the artificial store-bought stuff, and honestly… I’ve come to enjoy making these just as much as my dog enjoys eating them. If you try a batch with different flavor combinations (sweet potato is a good one), let me know what your pups think!
And if you’ve ever wondered whether homemade treats are worth it — they absolutely are. Make one batch and let your dog’s tail do the talking.
About the Author
Hi, I’m Mary Ann — the writer and creator behind My Tasteful Threads. I share easy, cozy kitchen favorites, beginner-friendly crochet projects, and honest stories from everyday life. From homemade dog treats to handmade potholders, I love the simple, practical things that make a home feel warm and lived in.
Join My Newsletter
Get cozy recipes, crochet patterns, and simple everyday living tips delivered straight to your inbox.
